Tag Archives: Copyright

Once You’re Gone, You Can Never Come Back? Golan v. Holder Takes Copyright to New Heights

“Out of the blue and into the black.  They give you this but you pay for that.  And once you’re gone, you can never come back.”  Neil Young

In “Hey Hey, My My,”  Neil Young lamented the fates of Elvis and Johnny Rotten.  But his lyrics could have applied as well to the fates of  many songs, books, and other creative works that originated outside the United States, were protected by foreign copyright, but had entered the public domain in the United States.  Those works  free for anyone to perform, reproduce, or use in this country.  That situation was a boon for orchestras, singers, publishers and others, who had a trove of material to use for free.  At least that was the case until the U.S. Congress stepped in.  In 1994, Congress passes a law to implement treaty obligations imposed by a global agreement–the so-called Uruguay Round.  The law essentially rescued a large volume of foreign based works from the public domain and put them back under copyright.

The law threatened to impose a hefty toll on users who had become accustomed to using those works on the public domain’s “freeway.”  So a coalition of orchestra conductors, educators, performers, motion picture distributors, and others challenged the law.  They argued that the law violated the Constitution, challenging Congress’s right to resurrect works whose copyrights had died.  They also complained  that the law trammelled their freedom of speech.  The case is known as Golan v. Holder.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in a 2012 opinion by Justice Ginsburg, rejected the challenge across the board.   The Court confirmed Congress’s power to restore copyrights, just as the Court had previously affirmed Congress’s power to lengthen their term.    The Golan v. Holder decision confirms that works protected by foreign copyright also enjoy the protections of the U.S. Copyright law for the rest of their term in their home country, even if those works had entered the public domain in this country.  And the Court showed no sympathy for the challengers’ claims that plucking works from the public domain would put free-riding performers on the sidelines or in the poorhouse.

So now, orchestras will have to pay to play Prokofiev’s Russian-born Peter and The Wolf,  just as they pay to perform Aaron Copeland’s quintessentially American “Fanfare For The Common Man.”  But the United States will be able to honor its Uruguay Round obligations, U.S. copyright law will be harmonized with international standards, and, to paraphrase Neil Young, everyone can “Keep on Rockin ‘In the Free World,” just not for free.

Quote of The Day:  “If music be the food of love, play on. ”   William Shakespeare

Leave a comment

Filed under copyright, Uncategorized

Marching To The Same Drummer: Hal Blaine and The Wrecking Crew-Coming To A Theater Near You?

“Lie la lie, [Crash], lie la la la lie la lie, lie la la [crash]!”   The Boxer, Paul Simon

Elvis, Sinatra (Frank and Nancy), The Mamas and The Papas, The Beach Boy, Simon and Garfunkel, The Righteous Brothers, Sonny and Cher, Steely Dan, The Byrds, The Association, Herb Alpert and The Tijuana Brass, America, The Monkees–these diverse musical legends seemingly have little in common, both in terms of their music and the personnel who performed it.  Appearances and sounds, however, can be deceiving.  All of these icons relied on one man to pound out the beat in the recording studio.  From the big drum echo crashes in The Boxer to the emphatic thud that kicks off California Dreaming,  that man was legendary session drummer Hal Blaine.

Blaine was not alone in providing expert, albeit nameless, faceless musical punch to the music of he sixties and seventies. He and a handful of equally superb musicians formed a collection of studio players for hire that became known as The Wrecking Crew.  Similar to the session men at Motown known as the “Funk Brothers,” the “Crew” could be relied on to create just the right  sounds and moods  through their expert playing and uncanny skill at devising arrangements on the fly.  A few of the Wrecking Crew went on to stellar careers of their own, most notably Rhinestone Cowboy Glenn Campbell, and piano player Leon Russell.  But the rest, like Blaine and guitarist Tommy Tedesco, remained unheralded and anonymous, not even earning mention on the liner notes of the many hit albums they created. But their work was prolific and prodigious.

The Funk Brothers’ unsung genius finally came to light through the marvelous documentary Standing in The Shadows of Motown.  Now The Wrecking Crew is poised to get the credit that is long past due via a documentary of their own.  www.wreckingcrew.tv   Tommy Tedesco’s son, Danny,  has a film in the can that pays homage to his dad, Hal Blaine, and the others.  It’s been shown and won awards and acclaim at SXSW, Sundance, and other film festivals.    It should be coming to a theater near you.

But there’s just one hang-up.  The Wrecking Crew played on so many records, for so many artists, on so many labels, that wrangling the necessary copyright clearances and licences for the film’s trove of music clips has proven quite the chore.  And an expensive one at that.  While the filmmakers behind Standing In The Shadows  had only Motown to deal with, Tedesco and company have had to haggle with multiple labels.  As recently reported in The New York Times, Tedesco says that “There are 132 music cues in this film, and you’ll know 99.9 percent of them. But when I asked one record company for a quote, they said it was going to cost $2.5 million.”  He’s been able to strike better bargains, but he is still short on cash to the tune of around $175,000.

According to the Times, with the music business on the skids due to declining record sales, digital piracy, and the stagnant economy, the record labels have tried to grab any opportunity to profit from their catalogues.  That’s spelled trouble for Tedesco and the film’s other producers.  But they have persevered.

Fundraisers, including a concert and an online campaign, are in the works.  Hopefully, before too long, the beat will go on and The Wrecking Crew, The Film will have its long-awaited  theatrical release.    Until then, we’ll have to make do with the trailer and all the great music that forms the Wrecking Crew’s true legacy.

Watch the trailer and learn how to donate @ http://wreckingcrew.tv/

Read the New York Times article @ http://wreckingcrew.tv/nytimes0412.pdf

QUOTE OF THE DAY:  “I didn’t realize the [bands] didn’t play on their own records until the Monkees came on [American Bandstand].”  Dick Clark

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Teach Your Children Well: Teller of Penn and Teller magic act sues over trick theft

“Try to understand, try to understand, try, try, try to understand. He’s a magic man.”  Heart

Houdini dazzled by flirting with danger and death.  Penn and Teller play it safer, mixing astonishing tricks with amusing banter and mime.  Penn is the banterer–quick with asides in his gravelly voice.  Teller plays the mute.  No one has heard him speak.  No one ne knows his first name.  No one, that is, except those of us to whom he was “Mr. Raymond Teller” when he taught Latin at Lawrence High School in Lawrenceville, NJ, during the mid ’70s.  To us, he was quirky, eccentric, cerebral, and fascinating.  We marvelled over his command of his subject as much as his mastery of magic.  He’d routinely mesmerize us with tricks that later became staples of his street act in Philadelphia, then his and Penn’s stage act.  One trick I remember vividly had Teller swallow a handful of sewing needles, then extract them by ingesting a piece of thread and pulling out the threaded needles one by one.  It sure beat calculus.

Now, Teller has sued a Dutch magician who’s threatening to reveal the secrets behind one of Penn and Teller’s signature tricks–cutting the petals off a rose without ever touching them.  The attached article describes the trick and the lawsuit.  Teller of Penn and Teller magic act sues over trick theft. Teller had the foresight nearly twenty years ago to copyright this trick, describing it in detail with words and illustrations.  He just may pull off one of his greatest feats, avoiding copyright pitfalls that have plagued efforts by fellow magicians to protect their original tricks.

Once again, Teller is playing the dual role of magician and teacher.  If his suit succeeds, he’ll have provided the roadmap for other magicians to protect their tricks.   And that would be some rabbit to pull out of his hat.

QUOTE OF THE DAY:  “What the eyes see and the ears hear, the mind believes.”  Harry Houdini

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

No Direction Home?: British Boy Band One Direction Hits U.S. Shores and Trademark Shoals

“How does it feel?  To be on your own.  With no direction home.  Like a complete unknown.”  Bob Dylan

Those old enough to remember The Beatles debut may be surprised to learn that another British Invasion is underway a generation later.  Back in ’64, a nation roiled by tragedy discovered a quartet of musical savants, boyhood friends who honed their chops in the dank basement clubs of Liverpool and Hamburg.  A gifted producer, George Martin, molded their virtuosic talents to produce the greatest library of pop music the world has ever known.  When the cadaverous Ed Sullivan brought their infectious music into our living rooms on a winter’s eve, he instantly lifted the pall that had blanketed America since that dark Dallas day in November of ’63 and changed the world of music forever.

Today, our shores are graced by another collection of British lads, brought together by an even more formidable  impresario–Simon Cowell, the dyspeptic English architect of American Idol and The X-Factor.  The man whose scowl has sunk a thousand careers and launched several others.  This time, instead of a Fab Four, we have a pre-fab five called One Direction.  This band’s music has been percolating among tweens and teens for almost a year.  Now, One Direction is shattering the mainstream in a huge way.  The band has a number one album, outstripping the latest release by American icon Bruce Springsteen.  And they’ve had their own televised intro to the American viewing public via a coveted performance on Saturday Night Live.

By almost every measure, the “one direction” these phenoms seemed headed was up.  Nothing stood in the way of their meteoric rise–nothing that is except “softrights’ in the form of a trademark claim by another band by the same name–an unheralded American group also called One Direction.  Hailing from Los Angeles, that homegrown One Direction claims to have coined its name in 2009, well before the British belters even caught Simon Cowell’s ear.

If the American band’s claims of prior adoption and use pan out, it could spell trouble, with a capital T that stands for Trademark Infringement.  American trademark law gives ownership of a band name to the outfit that uses it first in this country.  With nothing to lose and everything to gain,  America’s One Direction has fired the opening salvo in a legal dispute that could wind up sending the British band to the wings.  In their complaint filed in a U.S. Federal court, the L.A. band seeks damages to the tune of $1 million as well as an injunction that would force Simon Cowell’s proteges to pick a new name.

The dispute is still in its infancy, but already, the British One Direction faces a stark choice, either pay the piper to continue using the name under which its accumulated fame and fortune, or take its chances before an American judge and Los Angeles jury.

Whatever the outcome, Simon Cowell’s “direction” in building his next international super group will surely include a visit with a U.S. trademark lawyer.  As for the American One Direction, the answer to Bob Dylan’s questions from “Like A Rolling Stone” is hardly blowin’ in the wind.  With their lawsuit taking center stage, being a complete unknown must feel pretty, pretty good.

Quote of the Day:  “If you don’t know where you’re going, any road will take you there.” George Harrison.


Filed under IP